Skip to main content

Don't Time the Economy, Sell on Your Own Upswing

Trying to sell at the top of the economic cycle is mostly wasted energy; the timing that actually pays is your own company's upward trend.

The macro cycle is a trap​

The instinct is to sell when the economy is hot and multiples are fat. Warrillow argues this is usually a mistake, because the proceeds do not exist in a vacuum. You sell into a frothy market and then reinvest into that same frothy market.

"timing the sale of your business on external economic cycles is usually a waste of energy"

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 3

Warrillow frames the choice as Peak Seller versus Trough Seller. The Peak Seller cashes out at the top but now has to redeploy capital that is also priced at the top. The Trough Seller sells cheap but buys back in cheap. Either way the relative position barely moves, which is why he treats market-timing as a distraction from the things an owner can actually control.

Burlingham adds the harder problem: even if timing the macro cycle were worth doing, you usually cannot. He calls them windows of valuation, and they open and close fast. Markets are fickle; the window you are waiting for may slam shut before you are ready to act. The lesson is not to predict the window but to be prepared so you can move through whichever one happens to be open.

Snider reinforces the same point in the bluntest terms: trying to time the private capital market is the owner's worst harvesting strategy. He singles out the "magic five years" default, the reflexive "I'll sell in five years" answer, as a market-timing trap dressed up as a plan. His prescription, drawn from his Value Acceleration Methodology, is to build an attractive, ready business now so that it can sell in good times or bad rather than betting the outcome on a forecast.

"Forecasting the private capital market is likely your worst strategy for harvesting your wealth."

Snider, Walking to Destiny, ch. 4

Sell on your own promise, not the reality​

If the economy is the wrong clock, what is the right one? Both authors point to the company's own trajectory. Burlingham quotes Basil Peters making the case most bluntly:

"It's always best to sell on an upward trend. You sell on the promise, not the reality. ... The danger, if you wait, is that you'll ride the value over the top. Most entrepreneurs do."

Burlingham, Finish Big, ch. 4

The buyer is paying for expected future cash flow, so the moment of maximum value is when the story still points up and to the right, not after the curve has flattened and the growth is already in the rear-view mirror. Barry Carlson, also quoted by Burlingham, puts the same idea in the owner's own terms:

"You sell when the selling is good, not when you think you'd like to. Doing anything else, you run the risk of leaving a whole bunch of money on the table."

Burlingham, Finish Big, ch. 4

Note that "when the selling is good" is defined by the business, not the headlines. A company on a genuine upswing tells a credible growth story to a buyer regardless of where the broader cycle sits.

Readiness, not prediction, is the lever​

The practical upshot is that the work is preparation, not forecasting. Warrillow's antidote to bad timing is the pre-diligence package: assembling buyer-ready information before you ever go to market, so you can act the instant your own numbers are climbing.

"A professionally prepared pre-diligence package is a subtle but powerful way to create competitive tension for your business—even if none exists."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 3

Preparation also protects deal momentum. Warrillow's point is that fumbled information requests during a sale bleed buyer enthusiasm and invite deal fatigue, so the owner who has done the homework in advance keeps the tempo up and the leverage intact. Being ready is what lets you sell on your upswing instead of scrambling once the window appears.

There is also a one-way-door warning attached. Warrillow insists you never go to market just to "test the waters," because the attempt is largely irreversible:

"As they say, it's like bread: you can't un-toast it."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 3

A failed sale attempt permanently changes how employees, suppliers, and competitors see you. That is one more reason to wait for your real upswing and move decisively, rather than poking at the macro cycle to see if the timing feels right.

Steelmanning the timer​

The opposing view is not stupid. Sector multiples really do expand and contract, and selling a software company in a boom can fetch a meaningfully higher number than selling the identical company in a bust. Burlingham concedes the existence of these windows; his argument is about the difficulty of catching them, not their nonexistence. And the two clocks can align: the strongest exits often happen when your own upswing coincides with a generous market. The honest synthesis is that you should optimize aggressively for the variable you control (your own trend and your readiness) and treat a favorable macro window as a bonus to seize, never a date to wait for.

Further Reading​

Sources: Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business ch.3; Burlingham, Finish Big ch.4; Snider, Walking to Destiny, ch. 4