Skip to main content

The Art of Selling Your Business (Warrillow)

John Warrillow's playbook for exiting a $1M to $50M business on top, organized as a three-section journey: prepare, build leverage, then negotiate.

This page walks through John Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business: Winning Strategies & Secret Hacks for Exiting on Top (Greenleaf Book Group / Page Two, 2021), in the author's own framework. If the book is useful to you, buy it from the author.

Warrillow draws on hundreds of interviews from his Built to Sell Radio podcast plus his own exits. His scope is narrow on purpose: companies worth between $1 million and $50 million, where what he calls the "art form" has the biggest impact. He is not interested in selling your inventory and equipment. He is interested in maximizing goodwill, the intangible value a buyer pays for. As Warrillow frames the whole enterprise:

"The art of selling your business is getting someone to value something they cannot touch. In essence, they are buying a story about what your business could be in their hands."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 1

The book is divided into three sections that track the chronological process: things to consider before you start, building negotiating leverage, and punching above your weight in the negotiation. A final chapter handles the emotional aftermath.

Value Is in the Eye of the Acquirer (Chapter 1)​

Warrillow opens with Robert Ryman's Bridge, a square white canvas that sold for $20.6 million at Christie's. To him it looks like a high school cafeteria ceiling tile, but to the right buyer it is a masterpiece. That gap is his thesis: the same business is worth wildly different amounts to different buyers, and the seller's job is to find and court the one who values it most.

"One person's ceiling tile is another person's masterpiece."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 1

The point is not that valuation math is useless. There is a systematic way to calculate what a company is worth. The point is that the math alone gets you an average price. Warrillow's recurring warning is that selling well is more art than science, centered on packaging, story, and the feeling owning the business gives a buyer.

"There is a systematic way to calculate the value of your company—but if you're all head and no heart, you will miss the point."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 1

Things to Consider Before You Start (Chapters 2 to 3)​

Section 1 is what Warrillow calls the packing list for the trek. It covers the two questions an owner has to settle before going anywhere near a buyer: why you are selling, and when.

The most important question (Chapter 2). Warrillow argues the question most founders skip is what they are excited to do next. He distinguishes "pull factors," the things you are eager to go toward, from "push factors," the frustrations driving you out. Push factors are legitimate, but if they are your only reason to sell, you risk regret. He tells the story of Shaun Oshman, who pinned a sailboat to a vision board at 30 and sold his IT business at 39 to be living on a yacht by 40. Oshman took only about three times earnings, an average price, yet he was happy because he was going toward something.

"Pull factors are the things that you're excited to go do next. What are you enthusiastic about diving into after you sell your business? That's the most important question underlying this entire process—yet most founders never ask it."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 2

The danger of timing your exit (Chapter 3). Warrillow argues against timing the sale to the economic cycle. The trap is that when you sell, you have to put the proceeds somewhere, and most asset classes move with the same economy. He runs a Peak Seller versus Trough Seller comparison through the 2008 crash and shows that the owner who waited for the absolute market top and then bought an index fund ended up worse off than the one who sold in the trough. So he tells owners to stop obsessing over the macro and instead sell when their own company is on an upswing. Crucially, he warns that going to market is nearly irreversible.

"As they say, it's like bread: you can't un-toast it."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 3

The other half of this chapter introduces deal momentum and pre-diligence. Every transaction has a tempo, and the fastest way to kill it is to fumble information requests until the buyer loses patience. The fix is to assemble the buyer's diligence package before going to market. Warrillow quotes Barefoot Wine's Michael Houlihan, who treated the package as a way to manufacture competitive tension where none yet existed.

"A professionally prepared pre-diligence package is a subtle but powerful way to create competitive tension for your business—even if none exists."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 3

Building Your Negotiating Leverage (Chapters 4 to 12)​

Section 2 is the heart of the book. Warrillow's organizing claim is that leverage comes from multiple bidders, real or apparent, and that the seller's task is to drum up that competition without looking desperate.

The slow reveal (Chapter 4). Warrillow's most famous metaphor is the striptease. You control the dance by disclosing information slowly: a teaser earns an NDA, the NDA earns the CIM, the CIM earns meetings. Reveal too much too early and a buyer prices you in their head before you have romanced them.

"Information about your company is a form of currency, and as with money, you need to decide how to spend it."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 4

The enemy here is the proprietary deal, an exclusive negotiation with a single buyer who knows there is no competition and so makes weaker offers, drags out diligence, and cuts the price at the end. He warns that the smooth executive courting you over wine is not your friend. He tells owners to ask open-ended "what" questions to keep a fishing acquirer talking, and points to Dan Martell, who invited three rival buyers to the same event so each knew a prop deal was off the table.

"They will try to make you believe they are your friend. Don't believe them."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 4

Fish where they are biting (Chapter 5). Positioning. Warrillow argues acquirers sort companies into mental buckets, and your job is to place yourself as a leader inside the bucket buyers are already shopping. He cites Embanet moving from 3x to 13x EBITDA on the strength of repositioning, and Ries and Trout's classic insight that positioning manipulates what is already in the mind rather than inventing something new. He also relays Stephen Watkins scolding a room of founders for selling the wrong product:

"You make a few hundred or a few thousand dollars when you sell your product, but if you turned those same skills to selling your company, you can make exponentially more. You have the right skills, but you're selling the wrong product."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 5

The three acquirer types and building your list (Chapters 6 to 8). Warrillow sorts buyers into individual investors, private equity groups, and strategic acquirers, plus a hybrid PEG that rolls up an industry and behaves like a strategic. The strategic pays the most because owning you makes its own assets more valuable. He then walks through building a long list and choosing a broad, limited, or targeted auction against a proprietary deal. Chapter 8 gives the winnowing heuristic, the 5-20 Rule:

"The most likely buyer for your company is often 5 to 20 times the size of your business today."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 8

A buyer smaller than 5x cannot easily afford or absorb you; a buyer larger than 20x is too big for you to matter to them.

The teaser and the CIM (Chapters 9 to 10). The teaser is a one-page anonymous document whose only job is to earn an NDA. The Confidential Information Memorandum is the marketing document that follows. Warrillow's framing, borrowed from Theodore Levitt, is to sell the job the company gets done for the acquirer, not just the financials: people do not want a quarter-inch drill, they want a quarter-inch hole. He also warns about the risk of "getting naked," because some parties sign NDAs only to extract proprietary information like formulas or commission rates, so the crown jewels may need to stay back.

Telling employees (Chapter 11). Warrillow is blunt that the morally comfortable answer and the strategically correct answer diverge. Telling rank-and-file staff before close usually triggers panic, leaks, and slipping results, which costs leverage. He splits the team into need-to-know-now and told-after-close, and uses stay or success bonuses to retain key managers.

"The morally 'right' answer is to tell your team—but that is one of the single biggest mistakes you can make in selling your company."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 11

Your number (Chapter 12). Warrillow separates what the business is worth in the market (assets, DCF, comparables) from what it is worth to you personally. The hard rule is never to name your number first. He also warns against benchmarking a small private company against large public multiples, because small companies trade at deep discounts.

"If you blurt out your number, you will forever put a hard ceiling on what your company is worth in the eyes of the potential buyer."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 12

Punching Above Your Weight (Chapters 13 to 16)​

Section 3 is the negotiation recipe, premised on the leverage built in Section 2.

Getting multiple offers (Chapter 13). Warrillow argues that drumming up offers is a "who, not how" question: hire the right intermediary rather than do it yourself. He tiers them by deal size: a business broker for the smallest deals, an M&A professional in the middle, an investment banker for the largest, and he warns against being a firm's smallest or largest client. He also insists the intermediary work only for you, sell-side, with no loyalty to repeat buyers.

Price versus terms (Chapter 14). The chapter title captures the acquirer's adage that the seller can set the price if the buyer sets the terms. Warrillow casts the specialist M&A attorney as your "left tackle" who protects your blind side, separates the usually non-binding LOI from the binding definitive agreement, and explains how signing a no-shop clause collapses your leverage. He arms the seller against re-trading, distinguishing legitimate re-trades (a material problem surfaces in diligence) from bad-faith bait-and-switch, and offers the no-re-trading handshake.

"You set the price, I'll set the terms."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 14

Structuring your post-sale role (Chapter 15). Warrillow lays out four roles: lender via a seller note, division executive via an earnout, consultant on a fee, and shareholder via a recapitalization that sets up a "second bite of the apple." His central caution is to treat earnout money as gravy, because the new owner controls your P&L and has little incentive to help you hit targets. He cites Rod Drury, who left Quest before collecting a dollar of Aftermail's earnout.

"I never counted the earnout... I think [you should count an] earnout as a bit of a bonus."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 15

The art of the nudge (Chapter 16). The negotiation capstone. Warrillow's premise is that you take any offer, however low, and calmly nudge it up. The tactics: clarify your BATNA (keeping the business, or being your own other bidder); apply the "magic of adjustments" by normalizing the P&L so the profit being multiplied grows even when the multiple is fixed; and quantify the acquirer's upside, showing the deal is accretive and that owning you helps the buyer sell more of its own products. Stephanie Breedlove sold her $9 million payroll company for $54 million by making a quantitative strategic case rather than just asking for more, and Gary Miller moved IBM from 3x to nearly 11x EBITDA by staying composed.

"It never, ever works—at least that I've seen—if you start to get angry over things. That's where business owners make such big mistakes."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 16 (Gary Miller)

The Freedom Paradox (Chapter 17)​

The emotional capstone rebuts the stigma that selling is selling out. Warrillow argues that a business that once delivered freedom slowly takes it back as it grows, concentrating your net worth and consuming your mental bandwidth. As the company becomes a larger share of your wealth you grow risk-averse, the "Bob Dylan effect," shifting from the company's biggest driver to its main drag. Joey Redner sold Cigar City rather than take on $20 million more debt; Tim Ferriss sold BrainQUICKEN because, in his words, his brain felt like a computer running antivirus software in the background. Warrillow's closing reframe is that exit is not a moral failing but the natural end of a job well done.

"Starting a business is not a life sentence. Nowhere is it written that you have to own it forever."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 17

"Selling your business is the natural culmination of a job well done."

Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business, ch. 17

Further Reading​

Sources: Warrillow, The Art of Selling Your Business ch.1-17.